Home Politics How Important Is a Vice President to a US Election Ticket?

How Important Is a Vice President to a US Election Ticket?

by Scott Kacsmar
0 comment
Biden Harris

The focus right now on the 2024 US presidential election is on the vice presidential choices. Democrats have been attacking JD Vance, the Republican pick by Donald Trump, and we are waiting to see who Kamala Harris chooses as her Democratic running mate and the microscope they’ll be put under immediately.

Vice presidents usually do not get this much attention, but it has been an important part of the 2020 and 2024 elections due to the ages of Joe Biden and Trump, the oldest candidates to ever earn a party’s nomination.

We have already seen this have an impact as Biden announced in July that he will not seek reelection, opening the door for Vice President Harris to run in his place in November.

With the Republicans choosing Vance, some feel it offers them little since Ohio, the state where he’s a Senator, was already expected to vote for Trump again as it did in 2016 and 2020.

Meanwhile, pundits are imploring Harris to choose someone who will help her win a key swing state such as Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro or Arizona Senator Mark Kelly.

But just how important is it to pick a vice president to help you win a single state? Does picking a sitting politician from a state even guarantee victory in that state?

We broke down the 11 people to run for vice president for either party since 1992, noting what their job title was at the time they ran, which state they served, and what their ticket’s election outcome was in their state in the previous election and the ones they were on the ticket for.

Keep all of this in mind as we prepare to place our bets at the top politics betting sites!

2020: Kamala Harris

Kamala Harris VP Campaign

  • Party: Democrat
  • Job Title: Senator
  • State: California
  • Election Outcome: Won
  • 2016 Election (CA): Won with 61.7% of the vote
  • 2020 Election (CA): Won with 63.5% of the vote (+1.8 increase)

Kamala Harris went from sparring with Joe Biden in the Democratic debates when she ran for president herself to agreeing to become his running mate in 2020. After serving as a California Senator, she is the 1st female vice president in US history.

Harris’ state of California was never in doubt for the Democrats, and they were able to win it by a higher margin than Hillary Clinton did in 2016.

2016: Mike Pence

Mike Pence Vice President

  • Party: Republican
  • Job Title: Governor
  • State: Indiana
  • Election Outcome: Won
  • 2012 Election (IN): Won with 54.1% of the vote
  • 2016 Election (IN): Won with 56.5% of the vote (+2.4 increase)
  • 2020 Election (IN): Won with 57.0% of the vote (+0.5 increase)

Mike Pence was a single-term Governor of Indiana (2013-17) after serving in the House of Representatives from 2001 to 2013. He initially endorsed Ted Cruz in the 2016 election, but he then endorsed Trump once it was clear who had the party’s nomination.

Indiana has been a reliable state for Republicans in the election, and with Pence on the ticket in 2016, Trump won it by 2.4 more percentage points than Mitt Romney did in 2012. Trump and Pence also won Indiana with 57% of the vote in 2020 but lost the general election to Biden and Harris.

2016: Tim Kaine

Clinton Kaine

  • Party: Democrat
  • Job Title: Senator
  • State: Virginia
  • Election Outcome: Lost
  • 2012 Election (VA): Won with 51.2% of the vote
  • 2016 Election (VA): Won with 49.7% of the vote (-1.5 decrease)

Tim Kaine was a former Governor of Virginia and was a Senator in the state when Hillary Clinton chose him as her running mate in 2016. The duo was a heavy favorite against Donald Trump and Mike Pence, but things did not go their way in the electoral college vote, giving Republicans the biggest upset win since Harry Truman in 1948.

But Kaine did not disappoint the ticket in his home state of Virginia. While the share of the vote decreased by 1.5 points from Obama’s win in 2012, that was because of a stronger 3rd-party vote share in 2016. The actual margin of victory for Democrats in 2016 in Virginia (5.32%) was higher than the margin in 2012 (3.88%).

2012: Paul Ryan

Mitt Romney Paul Ryan

  • Party: Republican
  • Job Title: Representative
  • State: Wisconsin
  • Election Outcome: Lost
  • 2008 Election (WI): Lost with 42.3% of the vote
  • 2012 Election (WI): Lost with 45.9% of the vote (+3.6 increase)

Paul Ryan was the young (42 years old) choice of running mate for Mitt Romney in 2012. He served in the House of Representatives in Wisconsin from 1999 to 2019, and after failing to win the White House with Romney, he was later the Speaker of the House in 2015-19.

While Ryan was unable to unseat incumbent Barack Obama in 2012, he did help his home state of Wisconsin, a key battle state, make things closer with an increase of 3.6 percentage points. Wisconsin ultimately flipped red in 2016, during Ryan’s time as Speaker of the House, to help Trump’s upset victory.

2008: Joe Biden

Obama Biden

  • Party: Democrat
  • Job Title: Senator
  • State: Delaware
  • Election Outcome: Won
  • 2004 Election (DE): Won with 53.4% of the vote
  • 2008 Election (DE): Won with 61.9% of the vote (+8.5 increase)
  • 2012 Election (DE): Won with 58.6% of the vote (-3.3 decrease)

Joe Biden always talks about growing up in Scranton, Pennsylvania, but everyone in Delaware knows him too. He was only a Senator since 1973 and tried to run for president himself on occasion. He agreed to be Barack Obama’s running mate in 2008 and the duo turned out a dominant win with an increase of 8.5 percentage points from the 2004 election.

They did not sustain that number in 2012, but it was still another strong win in a safe Democratic state. When Biden himself won the presidency in 2020, he won Delaware with 58.7% of the vote, a 5.5-point increase over Clinton in 2016.

2008: Sarah Palin

McCain Palin

  • Party: Republican
  • Job Title: Governor
  • State: Alaska
  • Election Outcome: Lost
  • 2004 Election (AK): Won with 61.1% of the vote
  • 2008 Election (AK): Won with 59.3% of the vote (-1.8 decrease)

Alaska Governor Sarah Palin is one of the most widely criticized VP picks in modern election history. She was not well known outside of Alaska when John McCain picked her in 2008, and some of her awkward speeches made for prime-time parody fodder on Saturday Night Live leading up to the election where she and McCain lost to Obama and Biden.

In the context of how we’re handicapping this 2024 race, it seems insane to pick someone from a small electoral state like Alaska, which the Republicans already won with ease under George Bush. But perhaps picking a woman VP to counter the Democrats running the 1st Black president was on McCain and the Republicans’ mind.

But boy did it backfire. The Republicans still won Alaksa by a wide margin, but Palin didn’t even get higher turnout in her home state in 2008. The Republicans dropped almost 2 percentage points with her on the ticket.

2004: John Edwards

John Kerry John Edwards

  • Party: Democrat
  • Job Title: Senator
  • State: North Carolina
  • Election Outcome: Lost
  • 2000 Election (NC): Lost with 47.8% of the vote
  • 2004 Election (NC): Lost with 43.5% of the vote (-4.3 decrease)

Once upon a time, North Carolina Senator John Edwards was viewed as future president material for the Democrats. He accepted John Kerry’s offer to be his running mate in 2004, but the duo was trounced by incumbent George Bush and Dick Cheney. A Kerry aide later said that Kerry regrets ever choosing Edwards and they never speak anymore.

Edwards did not even carry his home state in the 2004 election. The Democrats lost North Carolina to Bush by an even wider margin despite Edwards being on the ticket.

Edwards was an early favorite to run for president in 2008, but his extra-marital affair scandal ended that dream.

2000: Dick Cheney

Bush Cheney

  • Party: Republican
  • Job Title: CEO of Haliburton/Former Secretary of Defense
  • State: Wyoming
  • Election Outcome: Won
  • 1996 Election (WY): Won with 64.9% of the vote
  • 2000 Election (WY): Won with 68.6% of the vote (+3.7 increase)
  • 2004 Election (WY): Won with 69.9% of the vote (+1.3 increase)

Almost everyone in our study here was a sitting member of Congress, the Senate, or a Governor at the time they ran for vice president. But then there’s Dick Cheney, who joined the private sector during the Clinton administration and was the CEO of Haliburton.

However, Cheney had ample political experience. He worked in the White House during the Richard Nixon and Gerald Ford years, he was a Congressman in Wyoming from 1979 to 1989, and he was the Secretary of Defense under George H. W. Bush from 1989 to 1993. His selection as VP for Bush’s son was a no-brainer in 2000, and Cheney went on to become someone viewed as the most powerful VP in US history.

Cheney helped Bush get almost 70% of the vote in Wyoming in both elections they won together. Wyoming was never in doubt for Republicans. But Cheney brought more national legitimacy to the Bush ticket given his experience. Most of these vice president picks did not have White House experience.

2000: Joe Lieberman

jo lieberman al gore

  • Party: Democrat
  • Job Title: Senator
  • State: Connecticut
  • Election Outcome: Lost
  • 1996 Election (CT): Won with 58.6% of the vote
  • 2000 Election (CT): Won with 59.6% of the vote (+1.0 increase)

Longtime Democrat Joe Lieberman joined Al Gore, who served as Bill Clinton’s vice president for 8 years, in the 2000 election against Bush and Cheney. It was one of the closest elections in modern times, and it ultimately went to the Republicans because of Florida.

But Liberman held serve in his state of Connecticut, seeing a 1-point bump on a state that was never in doubt for the Democrats. Gore probably could have made a stronger choice for his VP.

1996: Jack Kemp

Bob Dole Jack Kemp

  • Party: Republican
  • Job Title: Former Representative/Former HUD Secretary
  • State: New York
  • Election Outcome: Lost
  • 1992 Election (NY): Lost with 32.9% of the vote
  • 1996 Election (NY): Lost with 37.5% of the vote (+4.6 increase)

Jack Kemp lived an eventful life as hardcore NFL fans will no doubt recognize him as one of the most successful AFL quarterbacks in the 1960s for the Chargers and Buffalo Bills.

After football, Kemp stayed close to Buffalo and served in the New York House of Representatives from 1971 to 1989. He then served as the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development from 1989 to 1993 under President Bush.

Kemp accepted to be Bob Dole’s running mate in 1996 to take on Clinton and Gore. It did not work out, but the election results are interesting from this time as New York was not quite as Democratic as it is today.

In 1992, Ross Perot had a significant share of votes as a 3rd-party independent. He got 16.6% of the vote in New York, but in 1996, Perot only got 1.8% of the vote. Kemp and the Republicans lost both times, but at least the Republican vote did increase by 4.6 percentage points.

1992: Al Gore

Clinton Al Gore

  • Party: Democrat
  • Job Title: Senator
  • State: Tennessee
  • Election Outcome: Won
  • 1988 Election (TN): Lost with 41.6% of the vote
  • 1992 Election (TN): Won with 47.1% of the vote (+5.5 increase)
  • 1996 Election (TN): Won with 48.0% of the vote (+0.9 increase)

After 12 years of Republican presidents, Bill Clinton and Al Gore combined in 1992 to turn things around and win the election for the Democrats. This was a case of the young Gore helping to turn Tennessee blue, improving on the previous election by 5.5 percentage points.

This trend continued in 1996 when Clinton and Gore won reelection with 48% of the vote. However, when Gore ran for president in 2000, his home state did not vote for him, and Republicans have won the state in every election since 2000.

Conclusion: Harris Should Pick Shapiro or Kelly

Concluding our study, it does look like it would be beneficial for Kamala Harris to choose someone in a swing state like Josh Shapiro (Pennsylvania) or Mark Kelly (Arizona).

Maybe Shapiro would be the smartest choice since Pennsylvania is so crucial to winning the election, it has more electoral votes than Arizona (19 vs. 11), and it is close enough to where a popular Governor can make the difference.

From the 11 vice president nominees we just studied, Al Gore in 1992 was the only one who helped turn the tide for his party from the previous election. Tennessee went from Republican to Democrat under his watch. In the other 10 cases, the state election result did not change from last time.

So, the idea that a VP pick is going to flip that candidate’s home state’s election outcome from last time is probably farfetched.

With that said, 8-of-11 times the vice president nominee helped their state’s vote share increase from the last election. In the case of Tim Kaine in 2016, his party’s margin of victory was higher. The only truly bad performances at the state level were Palin in 2008 (Alaska) and Edwards in 2004 (North Carolina).

In a race that is likely to be close like the one in Pennsylvania, you could reasonably conclude that having the Governor (Shapiro) on your ticket would be enough to win. Keep in mind the Biden-Harris ticket already won Pennsylvania in 2020 with 50.0% of the vote.

So, even this would not be a flip. But you don’t want to lose out by a tiny margin like in 2016 when Trump won Pennsylvania with 48.2% of the vote to 47.5% for Clinton. That’s why the smart bet may be on Shapiro right now.

We’ll see what Harris and the Democrats do soon.

author avatar
Scott Kacsmar
NFL football picks are Scott Kacsmar's expertise, serving as his main focus. He has contributed to various sports websites and blogs, such as NBC Sports, ESPN Insider, FiveThirtyEight, and, JoeWager. Originating from Pittsburgh, Scott maintains a love-hate connection with the Pirates.

You may also like

JoeWager is your leading source for trending topics relevant to offshore gamblers, including betting resources, sports & casino guides, entertainment topics, politics and more.

Editors' Picks

Latest Articles

Copyright 2026 – All Right Reserved.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More